The owners of the President Arthur had cast a large net for passengers, and the group that left New York on March 12, 1925, had many different reasons for going. Among the passengers were:
- Philip Wattenberg, president of the American Palestine Line and a builder, who “plans to build hundreds of homes in Palestine for Jews who return there from other countries.”[i]
- Gizella Wattenberg, his 23-year-old daughter, who was stoned near Nablus later in her trip.[ii] “The only apparent reason for the attack,” the New York Times wrote three months later when she returned to New York, “is that Nablus is a fanatical part of the country.” [iii]
- Professor Arie Abileah, a pianist whose father composed the music for the Ma Nishtanah.
- H. Eisenberg, 67, of Astoria, Queens. A florist, he was carrying with him “more than 12,000 plants and shrubs which he intends to plant in a memorial park in the Holy Land. Mr. Eisenberg was sworn in as a Deputy Sheriff yesterday afternoon by Sheriff Mason O. Smedley of Queens, and will wear his gold badge during the three months he is in Palestine.”[iv]
- Abraham Goodall, an organizer and official of the steamship line, and his new bride, Ruth Lieberech, both of the Bronx, who had been married on March 8, 1925, on the roof of the home of David de Sola Pool. Reporting on the wedding, performed “in Open According to Palestinian Custom” the Times noted that the parents of both bride and groom “were among the founders of the Petach Tikvah, a Jewish colony in the Holy Land.”[v]
Although the ceremony marking the founding of Hebrew University was not featured in the advance publicity, it was the primary destination of Herman Hirsch and many of his shipmates. Others were responding to the call of Nathan Straus to rebuild Zion; still others went to visit Zion but not make a lifetime commitment. Whatever their reasons for travel, passengers on the SS President Arthur's maiden voyage were tracked as the American Palestine Line's offices continued its transoceanic hype.
Thanks in part perhaps to the “high-power radio,” the press monitored the ship's progress. On its March 17, 1925, photo page, the Christian Science Monitor featured the ship’s Irish captain, W.J. Breen, with the “first woman officers on an ocean liner”: Bernice P. Schmitt and Rebecca Adelman.[vii] On March 18, the New York Times reported: “First and second cabin passenger enjoying trip enthusiastically.”[viii]
Describing the first Sabbath on the ship, Hirsch wrote,
On Friday, March 13, we dedicated the Torah. A procession was formed and with songs and music we marched all over the ship. A chapel was provided and fitted suitable for services, and decorated with flags and flowers. Rabbi Ashinsky from Pittsburgh officiated and after his splendid sermon there was much rejoicing and singing.[xi]
Twelve days out of New York, the only other noteworthy event was recorded by Hirsch:
It was on the 24th day of March that one of the passengers – Mr. Jacob Drapekin of Chicago, who was making the trip to spend his last years in Palestine – died on the ship. After consultation with the Captain and Officers, Mr. Drapekin’s last request was granted – to be buried in the Holy Land.[xii]
On Thursday, March 26, as the President Arthur sailed through the Straits of Gibraltar, the crew and passengers saw a “huge” water spout, and changed course “to avoid the phenomenon.” As usual, this news was reported by by the offices of the American Palestine Line to the Times. From there to Haifa, the ship was escorted by a special ship chartered by “members of the Jewish community at Gibraltar.” [xiii]
On March 29, the New York Times reported that the ship “is due to arrive at Haifa today,” having “arrived at and departed from Naples on Friday [March 27].” The Times printed a statement by Strahl: “Lord Balfour, who accompanied Dr. Chaim Weizmann to Jerusalem to attend the dedication of the first Hebrew University . . . is expected to come down from the Holy City to greet the modern Mayflower.”[xiv]
[i] “Zionists Sail for Dedication of University.”
[ii] “Several Persons Wounded at Nablus,” Palestine Bulletin, April 8, 1925, 1. “Official Statement on Nablus Incident,” Palestine Bulletin, April 12, 1925.
[iii] “American Tourists Flogged by Arabs,” New York Times, July 4, 1925, 3. The Times article concludes: “when Miss Wattenberg was in Egypt several weeks later a fellow-traveler told her that some of the guilty Arabs had been arrested.” Herman Hirsch also describes the attack:
We encountered Arabs who offered to rent us their donkeys so that we could ride up the mountain, and after making the bargain with them we mounted the animals. Upon reaching about one-half the distance the Arabs demanded pay again. We refused and dismounted and began walking again. When within a distance of about eight hundred or a thousand feet from our destination a group of Arabs, about twenty-five or thirty in number, barred our way, refusing us passage. There was nothing else to do but to retrace our steps. As we started on our return journey the Arabs started to throw stones at us. One of the women in our party was hit and she fell down, bleeding. Then the cry came for us to run for our lives. One stone grazed my head, another my back. An arab hit me on the back with a heavy stick and tore from my shoulder my kodak which hung there. I surely thought that this would be my end. They had knives. O how I did run over the rough stones - my mouth so dry that I could hardly breath [sic]. I had, however, provided myself with some Holland gin, I hurriedly placed it to my lips and took a drink. That gave me new strength, and after repeating this a few times as I ran, I was able to gather up all my strength. I reached the hotel in safety, and a short time later the others in our party came straggling in and with them the wounded member who received the proper attention.
[iv] “City Bids Godspeed to Holy Land Ship.”
[v] “Marry on the Roof of Rabbi Pool’s Home,” New York Times, March 9, 1925, 17.
[vi] William J. Breen, Master. “List or Manifest of Aliens Employed on the Vessel as Members of Crew,” USMSS President Arthur arriving at New York, May 8, 1925, from the port of Haifa, Palestine, Sheet No. 206, No. 1. http://search.ancestry.com/Browse/view.aspx?dbid=7488&iid=NYT715_3648-1128. Accessed 12/8/09.
[vii] “Women on High Seas,” Christian Science Monitor, March 17, 1925, 9.
[viii] “Passengers for Palestine Enjoying Trip, Says a Radio,” New York Times, March 18, 1925, 23.
[x] Hirsch, op.cit.
[xi] Hirsch, op.cit. Rabbi Aaron Mordecai Ashinsky (1867-1954) of Pittsburgh was a founder of the Mizrachi Movement. He and his wife Pearl and their daughter Esther returned to New York from Palestine on the second round trip of the “President Arthur” on July 14, 1925. “List of United States Citizens for the Immigration Authorities,” Arrivals at Port of New York July 14, 1925. http://search.ancestry.com/Browse/view.aspx?dbid=7488&path=1925.07.14.President+Arthur.3&sid=&gskw. Accessed November 30, 2009.
[xii] Hirsch, op.cit.
[xiii] “Sights Huge Water Spout.” New York Times, March 27, 1925, 13.
[xiv] “Zion Liner Due at Haifa,” New York Times, March 29, 1925, E2. In fact, long before the ship had left New York, American Palestine Line officials reported that they had received a letter from Chaim Weizmann that he would welcome the travelers in Haifa (“Dr. Weizmann to Welcome Tourist on ‘President Arthur,’” Chicago Daily Jewish Courier, March 10, 1925).